Hacker News Reader

Comment by BelenusMordred | Hacker News Reader

The ROC(Republic of China) aka Taiwan has always held a constitutional claim to mainland China, they were driven out after the communist revolution.

Your statement is inaccurate.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiwan,_China#Background_and_a...

View on HN

Only about 10% of the population is descended from Chinese nationalists that arrived in 1949. The other 90% of the population doesn't want jack to do with China (nor, indeed, do many of the grandchildren of the nationalists, who have long since assimilated).

Genetics of the Taiwanese people is an absurdly spurious defense in this debate, I'd ask you to provide any sort of proof to your original claim that 'Taiwan does NOT want to “reunite” with the mainland.'

If you look at their history and policies it clearly does not feel the same way you do. There's a big wikipedia article that I linked there that says otherwise. Prove me wrong on this and I'll happily admit defeat.

A very well written cousin comment addresses your objections[1].

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29063869

I linked a wikipedia article that clearly states the history of the ROC, you linked a rambling conspiratorial HN comment from the exact person I was replying to.

Would you say the Republic of China does not claim dominion over what we in the west call mainland China? Yes or No? It's a very simple question that I doubt you will answer.

It is absolutely not a simple question given that the claim is made under duress.

To painfully ask yet again, does the ROC make claim to what we in the west call mainland China?

Is it really that hard to say yes or no?

There sure is a lot of "[citation needed]" in your vaunted Wikipedia article. I count 12 in the section you linked alone. Have you got any actually reliable sources, or just unsourced editorializing on a wiki that anyone can edit?

How about people in Taiwan do not want to have their free society and personal freedom destroyed by being taken over by communist China? Is that so hard to accept?

That has absolutely nothing to do with what we were discussing above and I suggest you read it again slowly.

It is exactly what is being claimed above at the beginning of the sub thread which you replied to.

It is completely tangential to my comment. Please take off your political blinkers and debate the issue reasonably.

Ok, but you changed the subject (what the Taiwanese people want and do is quite different from an outdated legal fiction maintained only because it is forced upon them). And I have no interest in debating that. Have a nice day.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com