Hacker News Reader

Comment by benjaminwai | Hacker News Reader

I think !$ takes the last argument on the previous command in history, not previous one on the same line.. at least in bash. For example, if you do:

  $ ls /
  $ ls /tmp/junk; rm !$

It's taking "/" rather than "/tmp/junk"..

EDIT: formatting

View on HN

Yes that's right it's the previous command from history. That way you run ls and see if it's the expected output, then rm to delete.

Point being that "ls /path; rm $!" deletes something entirely different than "/path".

What you want is "ls /path; rm $_".

Even then, the above is fairly pointless. At the time you look at what you are deleting, it's gone.

I think you misunderstood the previous comment. I think that firstly "ls /path" is entered and if the result is ok, then "; rm $_" is added to the copy of the command then executed.

Yes, at which point you simply do:

1. ls /path

2. rm <esc><.>

(where "escape" "dot" brings up last argument) without the need to fiddle around with dollar signs underscores, exclamation marks, etc. to prevent further mistakes (e.g. "was it $! or !$ ?", shell expansion, etc)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com