I use Neeva.com and I think one of their features resembles this idea. It is a paid for search engine though.
That's obviously not at all a knock against Neeva. Safari needs to allow more flexibility in its search engine defaults. I've filed multiple radars/requests to Apple to make this setting more flexible and/or provide Neeva as an option.
It remains to be seen if they can get enough people to pay in order to keep going though.