Hacker News Reader

Comment by lgierth | Hacker News Reader

I build them using Buildah, then mkfs.ext4, mount, cp, umount. It's a little bit annoying that I'm still using root at least for the mount part.

OpenWrt's build system has a method of building rootfs ext4 and squashfs images without any root, it's somewhere in that large Makefile mess.

(sorry, reposting this as I first replied to the wrong parent)

View on HN

No experience with Firecracker specifically, but if squashfs images are sufficient, one should be able to build a tar archive of the filesystem without root (where all the files have the correct owners, mode, etc.) and then convert it to squashfs using `tar2sqfs` in https://github.com/AgentD/squashfs-tools-ng, also without root - I've done something like this to create squashfs images in constrained build environments, which worked well.

I similarly have built bootable disk images with various tools including buildah and have never been able to fully get away from needing root for various chrooty/loopbacky parts of the process. In principle, it should be very possible to point grub at a filesystem-in-a-file and be like "install to that", but I could never make it happen; it always wanted to be trying to infer things about how to configure itself from examining the host system.

And yes, I've studied the OpenWRT build to no avail. I would be delighted for someone to dissect whatever it is that goes on in there and write it up.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com