Hacker News Reader

Comment by ashtonkem | Hacker News Reader

But a gallon of gas does something useful; it enables someone to be mobile and go about their daily activities.

Bitcoin is fundamentally a casino. It’s only legitimate function is betting on a number that’s not connected with anything else, also known as gambling. The energy we spend there does much less for a society than allowing people to move around and go about their daily lives.

View on HN

Ah yes, if bitcoin is useless them by definition all the energy is waste. That "if is important. It all comes down to "what is the value of bitcoin".

Not what is the value of bitcoin, what is the use of bitcoin. What function does it fill for a society in order to justify the energy expenditure? Manipulating a dollar value of something is apparently trivial to do, just look at the wild fluctuations in bitcoins price.

So far the resounding answer has been “number go up”. Well, that and crime if we’re being honest.

I'm pretty sure he is trolling... It is evident by now that the energy fueling bitcoin should better be used otherwise.

Just to clarify, not trolling. For those who think Bitcoin has zero value, then by definition all the energy is waste. For those that think Bitcoin has value, then the energy is by definition not waste and it's a question of utility, what is the energy usage of what it's replacing.

I noticed that you've asked a couple folks in this thread on their thoughts around that Square memo, digging a bit more into their thoughts. Wondering if there's something specific you're trying to understand around people's thoughts?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com