The first part is interesting, if you had been less verbose an ALL the different accounts you had it would have been a more interesting read.
There are still undeniable issues of using a password manager if you lose the data (or your master password is compromised but lets not get into that).
I've thought a bit about this in the past, mostly relating to setting remote shhd to disable passwords entirely, and only accept PKI logins - what if you need to get in, and don't have your key?
The google 2-factor with optional 'emergency 1-time use codes' that you can print and carry in your wallet is a nice solution to half of the problem (the other half being, if you're not using a computer you control, how do you securely access your password manager?)
I don't really have a solution, other than "remember to take your phone with you", and possibly "ensure that at least your primary email is accessible via 1-time codes or a memorable (and strong) password."
I use the Chrome and Safari 1Password extensions for 1-click logins, and it's a setup I'm extremely happy with. On the few occasions I've needed to access an account without access to my 1Password, I've reset my password via my personal email address and changed the password when I next have access to 1Password. I'm not going to pretend password managers solve all problems, but they certainly help.