Honestly, if the internet isn't required for the device to function, I think it shouldn't even be IoT in the first place.

I think automatic updates should be part of the device's default lifecycle because nobody will download a ZIP and stick it onto a flash drive to update their fridge. If an automatic update bricks a device, it should be exchanged for free by either the point of sale or the manufacturer because it broke during normal operation. IoT vendors have been given far too much leeway and it's time they're held responsible for the crap they put on the internet.