Is this still the case? Windows used to have an almost 45° lighting angle, but more recently (MacOS, Material Design) the more common case is the light source shining from the top.
Is this still the case? Windows used to have an almost 45° lighting angle, but more recently (MacOS, Material Design) the more common case is the light source shining from the top.
Top-left was used in the past because the only lighting hints was the edge colours, and this looks weird with a light that is directly above, so typically a 45-degree light was assumed.
In modern design, there is very little edge colouring used, and instead the light determines only shadow positioning. And shadows look perfectly fine with a light positioned directly above. This placement feels a bit more natural, as it doesn't introduce an arbitrary sideways bias.
The use of bevels has similar attributes to the edge-highlights of win 95, where putting the light from the top can make the left/right edges indistinct.