Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by tapoxi | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

tapoxi

It's part of the HN Cycle™

* Blog complains about Windows being a mess

* Comments about how the Mac workflow is better

* Blog complains about how the Mac is too restricted

* Comments about how Linux is finally good now®

* Blog complains about Linux desktop

* Comments about how WSL2 saved them from the nightmare that is GNOME/KDE/etc

repeat ad nauseum

View on HN

I do think it's finally become true (for me at least) that desktop linux is Actually Good ©

Previously on more user friendly distros like Ubuntu I didn't feel that the advantages over Windows were significant enough to warrant certain software suites being unavailable (adobe, autocad, etc.). And lightweight distros like Arch caused too much headache even with the wiki and knowing "what you were doing."

Arch now feels both relatively easy to use day to day, while still being incredibly customizable with almost no bloatware. The only real problem is certain almost non-negotiable utilities like PulseAudio not necessarily being as high quality as most of the user utilities.

Linux desktop is awful. At least WSL2 saved me from the nightmare that is GNOME/KDE/etc

I like the Mac workflow a lot better.

I think the Mac is getting too restricted these days, with the T2 and SIP and all

I'd be willing to try linux again, but the thing that stops me every time is having to go into terminal and start building my f'n software and manually updating or fixing some terminal only setting that is breaking things

I absolutely refuse to use an operating system for casual use that requires daily terminal knowledge and endless googling to remember and use.

It is what it is, but I do enough of this stuff professionally that I want an operating system that works from the second you push the power button with peripherals and software that work instantly after plugging in.

The second I'm digging through old forums looking for some multi-line arcane terminal script to paste to make things work, I boot back into something else and delete the linux partition

Obvious troll is obvious.

The obvious troll is describing exactly why most people don't use linux.

Except it's not a cycle, those are different people commenting different topics.

Its a cycle on HN.

Yes, if someone from one group states a position, someone from another group will rebut it. It's not a quirky pattern, it's just how discussion works.

This is hilarious because it's so true... There's also a conversational/argumentative style where you take the opposite position, either because you like to go against the flow or because you want to see how well the other guy's argument stands up to yours. I think if you look at my comments I tend to have a lot that are "well, no, <contrary idea because reasons>". If I'm at all representative of HN, it would surprise me if part of the HN Cycle™ is contrarianness.

True the gist of it is that people just like complaining and that the grass is always greener.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com