I don't intend to be personally rude here and appreciate that you're trying your best to do the right thing in this circumstance. I know there's some good Googlers out there.
But I'd have to say that it is absolutely shameful that desperate businesses have to try and hope to get noticed on social media to get a problem resolved. We all know that this is true. Not having responsive customer support is the way a scam operates, not a legitimate business.
Offer a paid customer support line if you must to reduce requests to a manageable number, but Google is absolutely killing off many innocent small businesses with the way they operate. Especially in these troubled economic times, it's absolutely horrific behavior.