Seriously? For one, this is basically a warrantless search which is illegal (obviously they get around this because Apple is a private company). Also, trusting algorithms for critical things like this is beyond absurd.
Let’s walk through this.
1. Criminal kidnaps child and abuses him. 2. Criminal produced video of said abuse and sells it on the web. 3. Criminal continues to sell it and it spreads. 4. The video is detected by authorities who promptly add it to database. 5. Video is cryptographically hashed and now anybody who stores this content in iCloud can be identified 6. A customer of the criminal is caught 7. Forensics leads authorities to criminal who produced the video 8. One less criminal to profit from kidnapping and abusing children
Everyone tries to make this approach as a slippery slope to facial. It doesn’t have to be that way if the right people are in the loop to blow the whistle.
Full whitepaper: https://www.apple.com/child-safety/pdf/CSAM_Detection_Techni...
This entire endeavor hands the keys to an unaccountable police state.
You are describing the reverse cause of targeted search for the individual in which each step has probability that is much less than 100%. The technology discussed is a broad sweep: everything, everywhere, every time.
Oh, well, no need to worry so much, Apple has just added data collection ability which others had in one way or another.
Most reductions of privacy toward the police would act as an effective deterrent to that crime and other crimes.
Deterring crime is not enough to justify a reduction in privacy.
For the second one, maybe, but I seriously doubt icloud encryption is going to do that.
Either way, just talking about baselines and percents is a good improvement over just "this would decrease crime". Add in the downsides too and you have yourself a good platform for discussion!
if you really want to put a dent in abuse, mandate cameras in every home because that is where most abuse happenes. Anybody who opposes that clearly has something to hide...
Police can always pinky promise to never use it for anything except catching the baddies.
Yes. For anyone who wonders. This is sarcasm.