Hacker News Reader

Apple cares about #1 when they feel the requests are not legal. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FBI–Apple_encryption_dispute

Apple has to comply with the law, however.

View on HN

What law prompted this new feature we are discussing here?

I don’t know, and I’m certainly troubled by the story.

There is a federal law requiring electronic service providers to notify if they spot such material. Apple may be subject to that. See the “Federal CSAM Law” section here:

https://cyberlaw.stanford.edu/blog/2020/01/earn-it-act-how-b...

Wow. Okay, so my theory about them trying to stave off future legislation is likely correct.

I assume 18 USC 2258A, but they seem to be going above and beyond. Under current law, they are only required to report, they are not required to prevent[1].

Presumably, they are doing this voluntarily now to stave off future legislation around this that might require more invasive scanning.

1. 18 USC 2258C(c)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com