Hacker News Reader

Comment by Jcowell | Hacker News Reader

I think this should be looked at a lens of what’s net gained and net loss. From my point of view , if Apple was to allow other engines on their devices chrome will be the de-facto winner.

No Apple is not going to try to make Safari compete with chrome , especially on windows.

No developers are not NOT going to use Chrome as their target browser and use Chrome push standards

Yes people will switch over to chrome since it will be the one browser developers will target for sure to make sure every hiring works. All it takes if for one website to recommend it in order for users to switch.

Ironically the only thing saving the web from complete Google Control is the opposite of competition. I do not see a scenario where competition does occur and Google doesn’t win. Especially on a service they’re not willing to put in their death bin.

View on HN

It’s fine, a lot of people still use Safari on desktop despite Google Chrome being available. And developers have to support it all the same

The same was true when IE dominated. The point being missed is if a single browser is allowed to dominate across the board, the owners of the technology become the gatekeepers of web technologies. That would have been extremely bad under Microsoft, and it is going that way with Google. In fact, there was a groundswell of negativity towards WebKit until Google broke the hegemony with by forking it, creating Blink. Which is now in a significantly more dominant position than WebKit ever was.

I’m not suggesting that Apple would be any better or that not allowing other browser engines is a good thing. However, the fact that they don’t is keeping Google/Chrome/Blink from having total dominance of the web.

I'm a regular desktop Safari user and you'd be surprised how many websites are just flat out broken in Safari, especially government sites. Part of the reason I use it as my daily driver is to ensure that the websites I'm working on get tested properly in Safari since the defacto browser for most developers seems to be Chrome.

I wish Apple would make a Safari for Windows or Linux. That the only way to test that your site works properly in Safari is to buy Apple hardware is certainly a contributor to sites being broken in it.

It’s not a perfect analogue, but under Linux, Epiphany/Gnome Web is a reasonably close match for most purposes. Not sure about Windows.

They had Safari for Windows for several years, but abandoned it because it didn't gain enough market share.

That is the point, they want user to complain to Site owners for not working on Safari and forcing them to Buy Apple Hardware.

Basically if you want to serve the 1.4B Active Apple Devices which nearly all use Safari, you have to buy an Apple hardware to test it.

The main reason safari is used in desktop is because other browsers are not first class citizens. They have access to resources that third parties don't.

Apple doesn't allow competition on their device because they know they can't win if forced to compete. Apple, even with all its resources, can only be spread so thin. By hobbling the ability to run your own engine, they don't have to try very hard.

This is the same reason they don't allow open installs. If they like an idea, they can compete at 30% more margin and with their army of engineers. Look how easy it is for them to enter the banking and movie businesses.

Keeping developers weak means they yield all the leverage. It's the modern anticompetitive playbook.

The DOJ can restore the balance by forcing Apple to open up compete fairly. It'll make for better software and products all around.

I assumed it was because they didn’t want users using the default, pre installed browser to see “this site works better I chrome” alerts on their i-devices

A sure sign they can't keep up and aren't winning over mobile web devs.

I don't think this is true. Safari on Desktop still has a considerable market share. IMO Safari is actually a pretty great browser. It is fast and power efficient, and much of the reduced feature set is stuff that I don't want anyways, like Push Notifications or PWAs on Desktop.

Btw, safari has its own API to get push notifications on desktop.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com