Hacker News Reader

Comment by toptal | Hacker News Reader

So, PBS seems to have done a documentary on this, which was just released an hour ago: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a2BIYWHdfTE

Did all of the media outlets organize together for months in advance to be able to release everything today? The content and production quality makes it seem like this release was planned months in advance.

Also, assuming they did, what’s the process all of these news organizations go through in order to plan such a release on the same exact day? The planning of the release in such a coordinated way is almost questionable itself, though it would be good to get insight into this.

View on HN

Hey, former software engineer at the Guardian here. Yes the news outlets are collaborating on stories too big for a single one.

The last I can remember was the Panama papers, which followed a very similar process. I seem to remember they all synchronized through the ICIJ [1], and more or less each journalist would cover their own territory / domain. Then they agreed on a reasonable date to release the news.

They shared more than just information, but also technical infrastructure to do the investigation.

[1]: https://www.icij.org/

So, if the ICIJ coordinated the last one, then who coordinated this one? It seems like Forbidden Stories is the main organizer though they also make it seem like “The Pegasus Project” is the organizer as well, which seems rather confusing.

You can't read the article?

> Forbidden Stories, a Paris-based nonprofit media organisation, and Amnesty International initially had access to the leaked list and shared access with media partners as part of the Pegasus project, a reporting consortium.

It looks like the Wikipedia page cites a broken link in concerning Forbidden Stories supporters!

[broken link #33] https://forbiddenstories.org/they-support-us/

"Prominent supporters are:[33]

Can Dündar, former Editor-in-chief of Turkish newspaper Cumhuriyet

Khadija Ismayilova, Azerbaijani investigative journalist

Marina Walker Guevara, deputy director of the U.S.-based International Consortium of Investigative Journalists[34]

Bastian Obermayer, Pulitzer Prize-winning German investigative journalist with the newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung

Fabrice Arfi, Co-head of investigations at French online newspaper Mediapart[35]

Will Potter, U.S.-American investigative journalist

> The investigation by the Guardian and 16 other media organisations suggests widespread and continuing abuse of NSO’s hacking spyware, Pegasus, which the company insists is only intended for use against criminals and terrorists.

Usually, joint investigations between multiple media outlets are released in a planned fashion. It's rare to see 17 news outlets collaborate on one story, but when "more than 180 journalists" have been targeted with Pegasus, it may be that the targeted journalists worked together on this investigation, using their exploited devices as evidence.

In the US, journalists were long reluctant to discuss Gov surveillance abuses in any meaningful way - even when they were targeted.

Snowden basically dragged news orgs into reporting it. After that initial rush tho, reporting was largely muted. Most DoJ and other abuses were minimally covered if at all.

That improved somewhat during the next administration but authoritarian deference still seemed in play to me.

>That improved somewhat during the next administration

I heavily disagree?

Are you asserting that journalists were more accepting of Gov mistreatment, during the Trump admin? That doesn't jibe with what I saw.

Fair point. It's difficult to determine much beyond that given the abnormal status of Trump.

The case around Jamal Khashoggi is also documented quite well in the documentary: "The Dissident"

It was that movie/documentary where I first heard of Pegasus and how it had been used by the Saudi government.

Looks like the same group of newspapers that also worked together on a number of previous high-profile leaks in coordination with ICIJ:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Consortium_of_In...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com