Hacker News Reader

Comment by Tempest1981 | Hacker News Reader

Tempest1981

Clicking "this device" shows a diagram of a sort of wide tapered straw... used to "cure" hiccups:

https://www.studyfinds.org/invention-science-cure-hiccups/

Huh. My hiccup remedy has never once failed me: - Sit upright, and ignore any hiccups till they're gone. - 1. Inhale and exhale normally for a couple breaths. - 2. Inhale extremely deeply, filling lungs to max capacity, and hold it (lungs full) for a slow 5-count. - 3. Forcibly exhale steadily until lungs are completely empty, and hold it (lungs empty) for a slow 5-count. - 4. Steadily inhale (repeating step 2).

If they're stubborn you may need to repeat the fill/empty cycle 2 or 3 times. 100% success rate for me and my family and friends. I guess the it helps relax the diaphram to take control of it and put it through its paces.

I do something similar that also works 100% of the time!

1. Inhale until lungs are at full capacity.

2. Hold your breath as long as you manage comfortably.

3. Breathe in and out slowly for a couple of breaths. I.e. don't gasp for air.

I also long suspected it may work by reducing the activity/stimulation of the diaphragm.

This might just end up doing the same thing with extra steps but for me the most effective has been holding breath until it starts to become slightly uncomfortable and then start drinking a full glass of water while allowing myself to take short breaths of air as necessary between swallows. Something about the swallowing motion combined with short breaths seems to "reset" the diaphragm like a champ for me. Breathe slow and relaxed for the minute after to ensure it's really gone :)

My routine is similar, except that my step 3 is a further “sipping” inhale, repeating your step 2 and my step 3 until I can’t take in any more air or hold my breath any longer. I’ve found that the initial “max capacity inhale” really isn’t that, but it takes some seconds holding that much air in at rest, with the trachea closed, in order to further inhale.

I think my version works because the diaphragm can’t spasm when it’s stretched (or contracted, not sure which) so far out from its neutral position. If I think of it next time, I’ll have to try your method out!

Anecdotally, a friend's mother can stop pretty much all hiccups by putting pressure somewhere on the wrist. I'm not sure about how it works, but it does.

Her own wrist, or someone else’s?

Any time I see anything about hiccups, my mind immediately jumps to this [1]. Rubbing your butthole is supposed to stop the hiccups.

Never tried it, but it is firmly planted in my head as random trivia.

[1] https://malct32.blogspot.com/2011/03/rectal-stimulation-to-c...

I think this is that device: https://hiccaway.com/general/

Reply on news.ycombinator.com