If what you are feeling is that scraping for commercial purposes feels "unfair," that is because if it is not allowed it traditionally falls within a legal cause of action commonly called "unfair competition." In the same vein as trade secret theft. So the law does square that circle, but the line drawn is a fuzzy gray one. Its unfair to free ride off a competitor, but yet some kinds of actions that look like free riding are in fact allowed.

How about a browser extension that scrapes only the the profile you are visiting and adds that information to an ATS. Just to prevent a lot of copy paste.

When Google does it, it's commercial, right? Should you need a license from all indexed content to make a search engine?

Isn't indexing for search what HiQ is doing too?