Hacker News Reader

Comment by mindwok | Hacker News Reader

HIBP has really grown from kind of a cool toy to a serious public good. Kudos to Troy for his great stewardship over the years, you can tell he is passionate about this and is very careful about making sure this dataset is used for everyone's benefit. I'm glad he decided to head this direction after the discussions of acquisition a while back.

View on HN

Yea, I feel like there should be some kind of internet nobel prize and that he should be one of the few to win it. He's definitely a badass.

The Swartz Prize? I like that namesake better than some others

—

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfred_Nobel#Criticism

"Criticism of Nobel focuses on his leading role in weapons manufacturing and sales, and some question his motives in creating his prizes, suggesting they are intended to improve his reputation."

> some question his motives in creating his prizes, suggesting they are intended to improve his reputation.

That seems backwards to me. Part of the purpose of reputation is to incent people to do good things.

Here in Scandinavia, the usual narrative about Alfred Nobel is that he wanted to offset the damage his inventions have contributed to the world. To acknowledge that, he probably felt that it was intertwined with his reputation and his own concsience.

Yea, people are fallible. It seems ok to me if he tried to make amends by trying to add a little incentive for people to better the world.

Yea, that name definitely gets my vote.

If his primary aim was to improve his reputation, wouldn't he have created the Nobel Prize before his death?

I think his brother died and newspapers thought it was Alfred and there were some very unkind reports about him that said stuff like he was a merchant of death and good riddens. That made him rethink his long term legacy and he tried to improve it.

Tim Berners-Lee should be one of the first in the queue.

Tim Berners-Lee is in the World Wide Web Hall of Fame, Internet Hall of Fame, Touring Prize among others https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_awards_and_honours_rec...

Yeah love the guy, saved me a few times !

Reply on news.ycombinator.com