Hacker News Reader

Comment by WDCDev | Hacker News Reader

Yes - and it's driving people further into tribes where the only way they feel "safe" is in and around their own "kind". This isn't civilization, but a regression and if it goes on for a few more generations it could be very damaging to our social fabric.

I just hope it's a weird early-21st century "intellectual" movement that eventually dies out.

View on HN

I hate to point this out, but this isn't a "regression" and it's been part of our civilization since our civilization became a civilization.

It's just a change in who the targets are.

I think it is entirely plausible that social media / attention mining / etc are absolutely making society less civil than it could be / has been.

Than it could be? I dunno. Humans gotta human.

Until relatively recently, women and people from racial and ethnic minorities were pre-cancelled. And if they got too noisy, there was far worse on the menu---the first year in US history without a lynching was something like 1952, and that's literal torture, mutilation, and death; not having people say bad things about you on the Internet.

Was it more civil? Yeah, sure. It would only be spoken about in public rarely and the better classes of people would certainly never face it. It would certainly be more civil, as long as everyone stayed in their place.

An entirely different class of bad behaviors that were commonplace in the past has absolutely no bearing on whether or not social media makes us worse people and just confuses the issue for no reason.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com