Hacker News Reader

Comment by idnefju | Hacker News Reader

Stopping world travel would’ve worked it out better. Like New Zealand and Australia. Suppression strategy with vaccines would have a solid effect.

View on HN

Here's an interesting geological fact about New Zealand and Australia: they're both islands! Believe it or not, it's much easier to control population flow into an island, than it is over a land border.

Why is it hard to police a land border? Cameras and weapons are effective deterrents.

The uk is an Island too and it didn't seem to help them

The idea is that an island helps with closing borders. The borders have been and are open in the UK.

It could have helped the UK, but you have to make use of it.

If "it's much easier to control population flow into an island" then you still have to step up and control it. The UK government did not even show interest in doing that.

The UK government mismanaged their borders, and most other aspects of the pandemic; notable exception being vaccination.

The UK gave up the ability to do that when previous governments decided to integrate our economy with Europe and build the Channel Tunnel. Every day, huge numbers of trucks travel directly from Europe to the UK with their drivers carrying all kinds of goods, including critical stuff like food for supermarket shelves. You may recall that this was one of the reasons why Brexit was supposed to be so dangerous and impractical.

There are many things that the UK government could have done at borders that they did not do, or delayed and did only when damage had already been done. It is a mischaracterisation to suggest that it was out of their hands, or that the UK faced unique problems that other countries did not also have, and handle better.

> Here's an interesting geological fact about New Zealand and Australia: they're both islands!

Not really, Australia is an continent not an island.

And to be precise, only Europe and Asia are connected by land borders (suez canal, panama canal).

More, UK is an island, also Ireland, Japan... and they don't have much less cases then the rest of the world

> Stopping world travel would’ve worked it out better.

The movement of people is a good thing. Hence stamping it out would have a huge cost, both emotionally and financially. The vaccines are comparatively cheap.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com