Hacker News Reader

Comment by Quekid5 | Hacker News Reader

What are they to do, exactly?

Optimization is a very 'generic' process and application programmers want optimization. The only sensible thing to do is to assume UB cannot occur and optimize accordingly.

What else is there?

I can already predict that whatever you suggest will very shortly end up in Halting Problem territory or will mean: No optimization. There are a lot of UBs that (if defined) would require run-time checking to define. That wouldn't inhibit optimization per se, but it would ultimately mean slower execution.

View on HN

C programmers prefer control to "optimization". And if you assume UB cannot occur, you should not generate code that makes it happen. Radical UB is not required for optimization: in fact it appears to mostly do nothing positive. There is not a single paper or study showing significant better performance for substantial C code that depends on assuming UB can't happen - just a bunch of hand waving.

I don't mean to be snide, but there's no paper on it because it's pretty much something you can learn in compiler 101. Without being able to assume that UB doesn't happen, useful optimizations become impossible very quickly.

You are being snide and inaccurate. Studies show 80% or more of GCC optimization improvements come from the core simple methods. Trying to compensate for the lack of data to support your argument by claiming (falsely) it's taught in an elementary course is weak.

Please link these studies, or describe your "core simple methods", because it is likely that they rely on programs not exhibiting undefined behavior. I mean, even the most simple optimizations like eliminating unused variables or inlining functions (what if you reach into the stack to detect these?) fall apart. These were taught within the first couple weeks of my compiler optimizations class, and I certainly hope that they were part of yours, because I can't imagine what you could have possibly gone over without starting off with this.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com