Wikileaks & Datacell to sue Visa / MasterCard for 'financial blockade'
wlcentral.org
wlcentral.org
The English speaking countries (I mean those whose legal codes descend from English Common Law) tend give more freedom-of-maneuver to businesses. The differences are stark regarding the issue of hiring and firing. In a country like the USA or Canada it might make sense to ask something like "Surely Visa and Mastercard have the right to hire whomever they like?" but in a country like Germany the answer would be "Of course not." (Specifically, Germany has a law for any business with more than 50 employees that gives the union a say in who gets hired.)
Regarding the right to transact freely, even the USA has several limits. For instance, you cannot refuse to do business with someone on the basis of race. But the EU has far more regulations of this sort than the USA does.
More to the point, this is a fairly transparent case where service was denied to a free speech organization without even the allegation of illegal activity on the part of the accusers. I wonder if skeptics would consider it acceptable if payment providers stopped processing donations for the Democratic Party?
Now imagine that the 3 restaurants/grocers are run by the KKK, refuse to serve blacks, and you are black. Are they within their rights as private companies to make you climb to the top of a mountain to not starve to death?
To me the treatment of Wikileaks amounts to about the same thing. The few companies that control nearly the whole international infrastructure for payment processing has come out against this organization, effectively making it nearly impossible for them to exist. If this is within their rights their rights need to be drastically curtailed.
Part of being in business is the business owner's responsibility to the society that they are a part of. That applies even more so to businesses that handling people's money.
Certain members of the government simply make unofficial suggestions, and the private companies _voluntarily_ block things.
Most of the stuff they do is borderline criminal activity, and it won't take a judge long to side with the credit card companies.