The "activity indicator color" one is "wrong" to me. It says "2h" by her name, meaning she was last online 2h ago, meaning that her activity indicator color should not still be green. Already feeling like some of these are one person's opinion, biased towards the current status quo in mobile/web. Although there are a lot of good points around padding, font, contrast, etc. Main theme seems to be around consistency.

Edit: Okay, well, I got

  7580
  Rank: PLATINUM (top 5%)
  Completed in 00:24:47

I think a lot of this was more "find the difference" than it was "tell me what version is better". Once you are able to find the subtle difference, it's pretty obvious which one is better, mostly because one of them lacks self-consistency. I think a lot of the tracking, color, and tint differences were pretty opinionated.