Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

KineticLensman

> Is there still a point to 2D maps?

Hiking away from cell towers and wifi

Historical maps

Maps that aren't owned by Google

View on HN

> Hiking away from cell towers and wifi

Just download the map in advance.

> Historical maps

Agreed on this.

> Maps that aren't owned by Google

I agree with this in principle, but there are alternatives to Google Maps and some of them are even gaining popularity because developers in general are terrified of ever relying on Google for anything besides ads.

> Just download the map in advance

Okay, hiking away from cell towers and wifi and power supplies

My phone gets about 4 days of use currently before recharging, and I could pretty easily find ways to recharge it even using solar power if I wanted to.

If you don't want to use your phone as a map that's fine, but it's incredibly convenient for (I'd wager) 99% of use cases.

What about redundancy. You drop your phone and you are lost in the wilderness. You drop the map, you pick it up again.

I actually just came home from a hiking trip hours ago. I was supposed to meet up with a friend along the way. I had a proper map. He only had a phone. Some rainfall and a little bit of bad luck and he could no longer use his phone. Luckily, everything worked out in the end, after some unneeded trouble. But I wouldn't rely on a phone like that.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com