A move towards making sales taxes less transparent in the United States is unlikely, because many U.S. founders associated with the Democratic-Republican party such as James Madison were influenced by the French Physiocratic school economics, which considered broad-based sales taxes to be a quite harmful method of taxation that should never be relied on as a permanent source of revenue.

This opinion is most clearly expressed by Joel Barlow in "Letters Addressed to the Yeomanry of the United States: Showing the Necessity of Confining the Public Revenue to a Fixed Proportion of the Net Produce of the Land; and the Bad Policy and Injustice of Every Species of Indirect Taxation and Commercial Regulation" (1791).