I don't have data but my hunch is that being a germophobe leads to worse long term health outcomes. Your immune system needs the exercise.
There's obviously a balance with the best outcome. I doubt washing your hands before eating will make your immune system any worse.
And I really experience a lot of people just not caring for basic hygiene at all when outside.
Both ends of this spectrum can also result in physicals health issues too. Get a stomach bug and end up with post-infections IBS. On the other hand, stress from fear of germs could also cause IBS. Sadly you end up with the same result. Both approaches, when taken to the extreme, can cause equal amounts of health issues.
In fact I would go as far as saying that breathing is a more common route of entry for pathogens than eating. The stomach contains concentrated hydrochloric acid.