Hacker News Reader

Dividends ought to not be at a tax disadvantage over capital gains for this reason.

Are they not? I thought qualified dividends (that is, dividends on stocks that have been held long enough to qualify for long-term capital gains) are taxed at the long-term capital gains rate.

You still have the one year of dividends taxed at the short-term rate, since dividends are taxed on disbursement whereas capital gains is only taxed on stock sale.

Dividends are taxable at the time of distribution; the price effects of a buyback are taxable when shares are sold [1], and delayed taxes are preferable to immediate taxes.

[1] unless the holder has elected for trader tax treatment, in which case shares are marked to market at the end of the tax year

The problem is also unrealised gains vs realised ones. I don't pay any tax on the stock price increasing. I have to pay tax on dividends.

If I don't need the money, I can just let it continue to grow tax free.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com