This situation stinks, for sure. If you want to protect yourself, use shadow volumes. Far better solution than questionable legal arguments.
As for shadow volumes, that's a whole other kettle of fish. I'm sure it won't be quite that simple - if your VLC history has a link to /shadow-volume/pirate_movie.avi then they may be able to compel you to decrypt it.
Granted, if we were working for the prosecutor we would be able to put 2 and 2 together ... but ... these are the same morons who just a few days ago grabbed an entire rack instead of one server, not being able to tell the difference.
You're giving them too much credit.
Anyway, as of right now, cops/prosecutor only get real excited if there's naked children involved ... and frankly, you shouldn't be doing that sort of shit anyway. Just jerk off to normal porn like everybody else, problem solved.
> Just jerk off to normal porn like everybody else, problem solved.
sigh
First they came for those accused of pedophilia, and I said nothing because I wasn't accused of pedophilia.
The FBI agents who did that are very much not prosecutors (and we still don't know why the FBI did that; it may have been intentional).