Hacker News Reader

Comment by verall | Hacker News Reader

This might seem facetious, but the cookie warning really threw me off. It doesn't really matter, I canbjust click past it, but instantly in my head:

"This isn't HN for anything. Some marketing something or other I guess..."

I think, for a dedicated/techy crowd, little things like a cookie warning mean a lot. To me it screams crap. I can't think of a single website I use enjoy using regularly that included a cookie warning. I think Reddit added a cookie warning when their UI went to shit.

View on HN

Hi, I honestly hate the cookie banner myself - that's why I made it as much invisible as possible. But I'm using Google's Firebase for user authentication and therefore it uses cookies. I also store your choice of theme dark/light into a cookie so it's there for you next time. I believe that's why I have to have the banner there. Or am I wrong?

You probably shouldn't backend on a Google service if you value your users' privacy.

The theme cookie is easier to solve: Use CSS media preferences instead and use people's browser settings to choose it. That being said, cookie warnings may not be necessary if you aren't storing anything personally identifiable.

Per my understanding of GDPR you only need the cookie warning for cookies unrelated to your site's fundamental operation. Admittedly, I'm not a lawyer and I've not really liked too closely at it, but I don't think you need a warning just because you use a cookie.

Firebase is easy to set up but pricey to scale and hard to migrate off of.

Firebase Authentication is free though, and very convenient to integrate off the bat.

Yeah, that's what I'm using - no limits on users or registrations or logins. Pretty good deal for an indie hacker.

I always thought that for purely functional cookies (like storing theme preferences) the banner is uncalled for. Is there a place I can read more about? I guess this varies from jurisdiction to jurisdiction? This (cookie compliance) is a mess...

What sites do you enjoy that don't have a cookie warning? I feel like almost every site does, except HN ofc

Reply on news.ycombinator.com