The internet and HN in particular, are full of stories of people who became rich overnight. But they never mention how many people tried similar things and failed.
I'm grateful for the story for exactly the reason you mention: it's a datapoint from someone struggling, not from someone who made it. And like you say, we need those datapoints just as much as the survivor stories.
It’s brought me more opportunities than any resume I’ve ever wrote.
It paid off my CC debt.
It’s connected me to some really interesting people.
It gave me the idea for my current startup which is growing nicely so far.
Couldn’t be happier with the outcome :)
If at all, HN is much better at showcasing failures than the rest of the interwebs.