BitTorrent trackers are more alive and popular than ever, and you always get what's advertised thanks to relatively high quality moderation (if you visit the right places, of course, sites like TPB don't count)
This is the soft power of the market at work. Short of refusing to create business presence or monetize, you'll never be able to get much of anything done.
If anything is to be done to force providers to raise the bar above a compelling, high quality piracy alternative, it quite literally has to be out of the goodness of contributor's hearts. Which means it must be so easy to build, people don't mind spending leisure time on it.
And assholes would still screw it up and ruin a good thing for everyone else. That won't ever change.