I’m saying we should change it so you have one of two choices for your website:

- let users upload cars, puppies, and funny videos of their kids (video platform; common carrier; immunized from copyright claims, etc)

- accept editorial control, and only post puppy videos, but assume liability for copyright violations (video provider; not common carrier; no immunity)

You’d be allowed to do either of those, but not the case now where you editorialize to just puppy videos but maintain immunity for that content.

As a business owner, you’d have to choose:

Are you a platform for others to host video or a provider of exclusively puppy videos?