Hacker News Reader

Comment by jan_Inkepa | Hacker News Reader

> Aired 10 years before the release of the first instalment of Peter Jackson’s movie trilogy, the low-budget film appears ripped from another age: the costumes and sets are rudimentary, the green-screen effects are ludicrous, and many of the scenes look more like a theatre production than a feature-length film.

I wish the article wasn't so sneering in tone... sneering is good larks if you're on board with it, but if you come in like "oh wait this actually seems interesting" it can be a bit off-putting. However, it is nice to know of this show's existence, and I'm grateful to learn of that.

View on HN

>more like a theatre production than a feature-length film

Because it was basically a "television play", a hybrid between a theater production and a higher budget TV series/film. Such things were common on Soviet TV.

One has to understand that Soviet Union was relatively poor when compared with the west, especially so during perestroika.

For example "Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves" is another Soviet tv play https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pCutJ-7acvg

TV plays also used to be very common in the UK.

The best adaptations of Shakespeare were TV plays. A lot of CGI is now trying to mask the lack of good plot.

I also think many classic TV shows are effectively TV plays - such as Star Trek, the Twilight Zone, etc.

You're right, that's a really fascinating observation. I can see myself noticing that on future shows.

You mean something like UK's "I, Claudius"?

From what I've seen on youtube regarding British TV plays, they were much much higher budget, and much closer to just a normal TV series/film, maybe with a theatrical dramatic flare, while Soviet TV plays often had abstract "modern theatre" like decorations, fewer or no background characters, other cost cutting measures, much closer to theater in terms of production.

Which, once you get over the low production values, is actually a very good series. Amazing actors, including Derek Jacobi. I once saw Derek Jacobi and Robert Lindsey in a play on stage, Becket, which had a few cloths and spotlights as props. These people can act. It was amazing.

I never considered it a bad series. We had it on TV even behind the Iron Curtain before 1989.

The production values of this Soviet Lord of the Rings strike me as quite similar to I, Claudius. And it's worth noting that the televised low-budget stage play production values of I, Claudius notwithstanding, it's one of the best television shows ever made.

Many of the original Star Trek episodes look like a TV play too. Lots of backgrounds that are just colored lights where today you'd expect to see some setpiece. It's all about the story anyway.

Soviet TV play adaptation of Asimov's "The Naked Sun". Has the best looking robots. (See the beginning of part 3 for example)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fQWLsZurF5U

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2YksNxkF2TQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BPamQ-khmf8

Actually it is a theater adaptation, but aired on TV. I remember that time. The Leningrad TV made plenty of similar TV-plays for children featuring actors from Leningrad theaters.

I find it funny that such production is compared with Jackson’s trilogy now.

I just went back and watched the BBC adaptation of Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, and those who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones.

Do you mean BBC TV? HHGTTG was originally a radio play made by the BBC (Radio 4), later adapted as books.

They made a tv show too, some of the cast being the ones from the radio show. It's definitely in the original doctor who style of special effects, and I really enjoy it!

It's like they pulled one of their Cold War era writers out of retitrment just for this article...

no, he looks like a freshly minted cold warrior. andrew roth should go and dig up scifi from bbc and compare "green-screen effects".

I love Star Trek TNG but it was about as “ludicrous” in a lot of ways.

I also grew up on Soviet movies and cartoons so this doesn’t look as out of place to me as I guess it might to someone who’s never seen this genre of film.

Totally :)

https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/startrek/images/2/20/Skino...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com