What I meant was that speculation and challenging the existing narrative plays a role in seeking the truth. So it has value and can be healthy. But it has to be treated for what it is - speculation. In this case, the actions of brokers should be investigated, and regulatory requirements should be scrutinized. But taking speculation as a foregone conclusion and resorting to an extreme reaction as such, is not healthy.

Without speculation there wouldnt be new theories. But ofcause its more risky than argueing in proven ground. Sometimes the risk materializes. At othertimes the speculation is a win.