We create value out of nothing everyday for ages.The fact that it is been done with the internet now changes nothing.
It's also not really created out of nothing. A lot of real work goes into making bitcoin a thing. Electricity isn't made by magic.
On top of that people seem to forget that market caps aren't real. Just because no holder of X is willing to sell for less than Y, and nobody is willing to buy X for more than Z does not mean all X is worth Y each or Z each or anything in between. The real value of all Z is impossible to know but probably less than Z each.