Hacker News Reader

Comment by toshk | Hacker News Reader

What if they take it further and also pull other google products like gmail, chrome, maps? That would cause some serious trouble.

View on HN

That's a terrible option for Google, because it's a clear statement that they see themselves as above national governments.

The large tech companies have been doing everything in their PR power for the last 30 years to pretend we aren't in the opening decades of a cyberpunk future.

Why break the kayfabe now, when they have the most to lose, and before their dominance is generationally cemented?

There are more countries in the world that believe the people should be in charge not venture capital.

Europe would close ranks pretty much immediately. As would New Zealand. Not so sure about UK though, but that's not a surprise to anyone, is it?

That would likely be an antitrust suit waiting to happen

It's just a hypothetical I don't think it will come to it, but wondering why that would that lead to antitrust case? My knowledge of law is non-existent. I thought antitrust suits are because of getting into a monopoly position. Are you arguing that such an action would leave them open to claims of monopoly? Forfeiting services might be seen as a form of abuse, but isn't it sort of opposite of an antitrust by forfeiting your monopoly / strong market position?

You're leveraging your dominance in some sectors in order to gain advantage in another sector. That's what they got Microsoft for. Also can't imagine countries bowing down to these kinds of tactics anyway.

Deciding that it's no longer worthwhile to provide services to everyone in a country is not leveraging your dominance. It's giving up. They can't force Google to operate in Australia.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com