Upgrade Your SSH Keys
blog.g3rt.nl
blog.g3rt.nl
Windows 10 has "real" OpenSSH client available as a built-in feature (and server available as an optional feature). Use Windows Terminal (or ConEmu/Cmder, per preference) for the terminal experience upgrades PuTTY used to provide.
Also a lot of suggestions in that quick search to try Ctrl+2 or Ctrl+@ as an alternative.
I bumped into this recently when I replaced my older rsa hardware keys with newer models. Switched to openssh for now.