if someone can do it for free, then it will be inevitably free.
While this is a trend, it might not always be true.
In France, Mediapart (mediapart.fr) is a website with a focus on investigation-journalism, built on principles such as independence from political/media groups.
Subscription fee: 9 euros (14 usd)/month. The project founders are hopeful to reach a sustainable number of subscribers (which is 65 000, 3 years from launch; they currently have 8000 subscribers after 4 months).
Conclusion: a high-quality customized product for a niche, although online, could justify the price - directly paid by the users - for that product.