Hacker News Reader

Comment by timsco | Hacker News Reader

Good for Hype for taking this problem on!

Has anybody with professional Flash animation experience used this product? I think that there is a great market for something like this but I'm wondering if it's ready for prime time yet. The demos are a bit weak if you ask me.

It may be worth $30 to find out...

View on HN

I've been doing Flash for about 9 years now, so here's my perspective. There are a couple classes of people that actually use the authoring environment.

Developers - Mostly looking a code, but may pop open an asset or movieclip to adjust the design or animation.

Animators - Tweening lots of layers of movieclips and audio. Apparently Hype doesn't do audio yet, and I haven't looked at how complex they can layer animations, think tweens inside of tweens inside of tweens. They also draw assets in the flash ide, so they need a vector tool.

Promotional - Split in to 2 categories Category 1 makes ads and promotional pamplets, Hype would work for them. Category 2 makes websites like the ones in Hypes gallery. Both categories need the ability to drop in audio and video from time to time though.

Edit - I think the biggest obstacle they may have is the lack of vector graphics, both at creation time as well as runtime manipulation.

Thank you. Great info. Hopefully, they'll add vector graphics soon. That's a big oversight in my opinion. That's usually where I start in Flash...

I bought a personal copy and recommended it to my team. We're currently looking into using it to create some generic widget templates that can be used as inputs to a widget-making web application I'm going to put together. (The general plan is to enable our internal customers to create their own quizzes, interactive training, etc. by filling in some HTML forms, while ensuring that branding and so on remains consistent.)

My opinion is that Hype is great at what it does, which is allow you to create simple animations. It doesn't have anywhere near the number of features as Flash, but maybe that's a good thing. If you're comfortable with JavaScript and/or you're happy to take Hype's output and manipulate it further then I think you'll be delighted. And for $30 I really feel like I am stealing from them! (Maybe this public advocacy will go some way to restoring the balance.)

There was a discussion on it yesterday:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2568464

I doubt a majority of HNers saw the original submission.

Edit: To the pedantic downvoters, do you have to be completely hostile all the time? This is exactly the crap that is making HN a worse community-- a bunch of egotistical trolls chasing superiority highs. The problem is the trolls are more motivated to downvote than the normal people are willing to upvote, so eventually all interaction will be suppressed other than the few voiced the hive-mind accepts and agrees with.

~200 points, on the front page for at least a day.

I could understand if it was something that had tons of duplicates, but it's not that big of a deal when a company is still relatively unknown.

I didn't catch the other article, not everyone logs in within a 24 hour period. I found the article useful despite it being a resubmission and I otherwise wouldn't have heard about the company--apparently 37 other people agree.

It's cool. I really don't care either way - didn't flag it.

timsco was first post, the submission was still on /newest, had few points. It would have been silly not to point to the previous discussion.

Also: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2569644

Peace ;)

Thanks for the link. It was a long weekend in Canada, and I went 48 hours without Internet access! ;)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com