Hacker News Reader

Comment by elliptical | Hacker News Reader

I asked someone to hand code. This guy was so used to Dreamweaver, that he could not just remember certain code, like mysql query. But on the DMW, he was fine, clicking away, getting stuffs done.

So the best coders are hand coders?

View on HN

No. The best coders are the coders who produce the best code.

hmm...even if they cannot code or remember the syntax without the help of the IDE?

In that case it is their manager's responsibility to ensure they have access to the IDE. The important thing is how effective the combination of programmer + hardware + software + other working conditions is. I don't see that considering a coder in isolation is terribly useful.

If it is the testing process for an interview then?

It's the interviewer's job to decide what they're testing for. Some developers need an IDE - that does not make them bad developers.

An interviewer should ask

    How can we help you show us why
    you'd be good for this job?

Stupid tricks don't help you determine if someone can do a job. Tiny, trivial programming tasks don't tell you if someone can do the job, but can (sometimes) tell you if someone can't do the job.

Interviewing is hard, there are no short cuts. You need someone who is smart, will get things done, can interact usefully with others, and adds value. Sometimes using an IDE is the best way to accomplish that - why ignore someone just because they don't work the way you do?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com