Hacker News Reader

Comment by FartyMcFarter | Hacker News Reader

> unusually good language for just getting shit done.

I agree, but only for very specific/small values of "shit".

A codebase with thousands of lines of Python is IMHO already stretching the limits of readability; when you get to the tens/hundreds of thousands of lines, it's definitely past.

View on HN

Not really. I've worked 9 years on a 200kloc -> 300kloc code base. It's not a problem.

What do you use instead?

I've tried and used 10-15 programming languages in my days, and while I haven't used them all professionally Python is still by far my preferred language out of all that I've tried. TypeScript comes in at a close second, although it depends a lot on what you use it for of course.

I've managed to write both buggy and working code in all languages, and can't say that Python is more buggy than any other. Slower at runtime, for sure. But not less correct.

Not the person you replied to, but I was a big Python fan until I found Scala. I try to write code that looks like Python (which means avoiding some libraries that rely too heavily on symbol-heavy names), but the type system can help me check that I really know the things I think I know, and even in small Python scripts there are conveniences that I miss (e.g. case classes - though nowadays attrs is more or less equivalent).

Correctness is not necessarily the issue. The hard thing with large Python codebases is that the lack of types and data definitions makes it hard to understand what data any piece of code is operating on. This may not be an issue for a project written/read by a single person, but when working on big team projects it's a different story.

Any statically-typed language will avoid this issue.

Python supports type annotations and static typing via mypy and co. I find statically typed Python is absolutely comparable to other statically typed languages. At least I don't feel much of a difference working with it compared to go, typescript.

I think Python is the language I wrote largest variety of programs in.

I recently tried to get stream of controller locations from Steam VR.

I was stumbling around looking for information about that in any language and the thing became a breeze only after I found Python bindings for it.

I never done commercial work in Python in my life. I did PHP, some Java, some Ruby, C# and JavaScript. But I keep encountering Python in stuff I do out of curiosity.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com