Hacker News Reader

Then you will be the one presenting a new bogus value on every page load – something that makes you recognizable as part of a very small group. As explained in the article, random values are not the way.

View on HN

I do not agree. First, being recognized as part of a group is better privacy-wise than being uniquely identified. And second, yes your unusual values will stand out, but as they always change, it makes it harder to link the browsing sessions together, and lower the confidence of the algorithm. It makes it harder to _track_ the profile in the long term.

Fingerprinting works by grouping people. The smaller the group, the better. And the group where values change constantly is bound to be very small.

Your assumption seems to be that these changes won’t be recognized. But they are very easy to recognize, e.g. by grouping the values by IP address. Same IP address but constantly changing random values? Yes, that’s a very reliable fingerprint.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com