Ask HN: Am I insane for competing in this space? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Am I insane for competing in this space?

5 pointsbenji-york8 comments

I think the existing mobile messaging apps/services are both too general and too hard to use for the average non-geek. Therefore I built a service with a narrow focus: group texting with the people in your family.

Is this a waste of my time or a good way to reach real users with real needs? The site is up at textmyfamily.com.

View on HN

There are a lot of people in this space. By specializing your sign up is slightly more streamlined than groupme .. but only slightly -- http://groupme.com/ -- how do you see yourself comparing with them?

Clickable link: http://textmyfamily.com/

In a way I'm going for a worse-is-better tactic. It doesn't do everything GroupMe does, but -- as you say -- that means it can be simpler: there's less to configure, you don't have to download an app, you don't need a smart phone, and you don't need to know anything other than how to text (which, after all, not all mobile phone users even know how to do).

That is a great focus. Remember the "Internet Buttons" app/site that was featured a while back? If your app is designed with that audience in mind, I think you could have a great opportunity. Best of luck.

I think if it's a good idea, the space will be competitive. If you have passion for the space, give it all you got. When you do that, only good things will come out at the other end.

With that being said, you still have to focus on your execution. If you take care of the smallest details and really worry about the users' experience/flow. It will show through and sure enough you might have that chance to fight with any bigger guy in your space.

Good luck and keep on fighting :)

Ooooh. You know what I was thinking? You have a "night" theme on your site. What if, based on the hours of the day, it will switch to "daytime" where there's the sun and green grass etc. It will make "some" people happier and that's all the "personal" feeling you need for now.

Definitely think there's a big market for this. I consider myself barely a hacker (if that), but compared to most of the people in my life, I'm a super-geek. Don't assume even 3% of your target market is HN-level.

I think that's a great idea and great focus.

What about Beluga?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com