Hacker News Reader

> Nowhere did I say that musicians shouldn't learn scales. That's absurd.

Yes you absolutely did. Your whole point is that 11/12ths of musicians' muscle memory is needlessly redundant. Let's see what you got that is better than this. You use a fully transposing MIDI keyboard and play everything on the white keys, am I right?

View on HN

You are so desperate to argue with me, you aren't even bothering to comprehend what I have to say.

Get over yourself. Or not. I don't care.

So far all you've done is say "I already showed you" for everything, instead of showing me anything. Except that accordion nightmare keyboard. You keep making assertions then when called on it resort to personal attacks. I specifically retorted to your muscle-memory quote with your own quote about the 11/12ths of effort, and apparently you didn't appreciate what you had to say for yourself. Your rhetoric is much better than your grasp of facts.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com