1) Keep it civil.
2) If you are going to make large jumps of logic like the one you've made, then that's fine. Just spell out what you are saying and why you are saying it because as it stands, I agree that your original comment seems very offtopic.
2. I made no "large jumps of logic" like I said, it was open speculation. Now please get off your high horse and quit repeating things that have already been said--everything you assert in your second point is proving wrong in my previous comment.
Do you not realize you're just discouraging people asking questions? That's essentially what you're advocating.
2) You asked for an explanation, so I gave you an honest one. If you don't want to hear it, don't ask next time.