Hacker News Reader

Comment by k_sze | Hacker News Reader

Technically commendable. But please please please stop contributing to PDF, especially in the conversion to PDF. It’s a horrible format.

View on HN

I am sure you have an alternative suitable and ready for the masses?

HTML.

Accessible, lighter, works on screen readers, extensible, a standard.

You forgot the horror of printing and rogue JS assisted bitcoin mining.

Printing can actually be fixed with the right CSS. The opposite is not true for PDF: you can't fix PDF for responsive rendering.

As for rogue JS, there are good, open-source countermeasures such as dompurify.

Sure, once we settle one one specific browser, that might be a good idea for publishing things. I have yet to see a HTML with CSS that renders the same on every browser. (A blank page does not count!)

epub 2 and epub 3 are both much better formats than PDF if you really want to publish ebooks.

PDF is not reflowable and results in a crappy reading experience unless the device screen size is just right.

PDF is ultimately for paper when you care about how the content fits on each page. A reflowable format will have to at some point be rendered to pages if one is to go to paper, and I can't think of anything better than PDF for storing that rendering.

epub is basically many html files packaged together and indexed. So rendering for printing can be taken care of with the right media-querying CSS.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com