Hacker News Reader

Comment by franciscop | Hacker News Reader

That is the same if you use e.g. styled components with React, where every component is self-contained and doesn't leak the styles. The mechanism is different, but the end result is the same, and oh it's a game changer IMHO.

View on HN

The difference is that web components provide browser supports low level APIs which frameworks can use to make isolated components.

Sure, you can get the same effect in React. But that only works if everyone on your page is playing by the same rules and using React.

I can drop a web component into some legacy page which is full of old school jQuery and global CSS styles and my component will be isolated and work. Try the same trick with React in that situation and it will likely conflict terribly and get stomped by the old legacy code.

But why should developers have to use a framework like React to do something the browser could provide for them? Not everyone is writing a JS application. Some just need to add some custom HTML, CSS and little bit of JS.

I don't think the GP was arguing against that. If you're already committed to an existing build process building new components as web components doesn't really have many advantages vs a component built in react. It's just adding needless complexity.

Web components can be built separately to the rest of an application as standalone components and included by adding a <script> tag, and then using them is as straightforward as using an HTML tag. You need a build process for the component (or the author of the component does..) but you don't need one for the website you're using it in. You can do that with a React component as well but you don't get the benefits of things like styled components if you do. You do with web components.

you can make your component's css "not leak" if you name all it's classes with random uuid and scope all selectors accordingly, exactly what styled components does. But "not leaking css" is a nicer way of saying that you can't customize it.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com