4 is a strawman. The comment you are replying to did not say 100% details, it said "a methods section that allows a third party to fully recreate your experiment."
What is possible is the following. It's sufficient that the paper has the crucial details. And whoever tries to replicate will still have to apply some creativity, change some details, and learn some skills, and ultimately get slightly different results.
In other words, enough detail to "fully recreate [any sufficiently complicated] experiment" is not possible to write down. Obviously, I am not providing any evidence for my position, besides my personal observations.