> It’s an old idea that keeps resurfacing and frankly I think it misses the real problem of modern websites: they’re too bloated with code that the user is expected to run and yet isn’t there to serve the user.
I agree that the latter is a problem with many modern websites. That, however, does not mean that this approach does not have a place; many people (especially people among the HN and HN-adjacent crowd, who tend towards simple layouts and static site generators) optimise their sites as much as is reasonably possible, and specifically, don't pessimise their sites with megabytes of tracker & ad scripts. For those people, instant.page might well be a worthwhile optimisation.