Hacker News Reader

There are similar analogies to bird songs.

In bird studies, one bird species can be raised completely around a foreign bird species until they learn the foreign songs, yet the native fledgling will sing the new notes in their own species specific patterns (as if there is a neural template).

I'm not a linguistic professional, but I imagine humans have some hardwired language patterns and others that are historical artifacts.

View on HN

Or it could just be because they are different species - that means different vocal chords, different brains, different ears and so on. It's equivalent to saying "chimpanzees act like baby humans when taught to play with blocks, yet still retain distinctive means of movement".

That study was about the presence of a neural template (and perhaps a linguistic one). Before the study people thought it might be possible for any singing bird to sing any other bird's songs.

An abstracted view of the point of the study is perhaps there is some hardwiring in our communication. Kernels of hardwiring that can't be nurtured away. In humans it would be analogous to the universal laws of linguistics.

It was just something to think about. Next time I'll just link the study.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com