Devil's advocate: Would a human pilot be skilled and lucky enough to pull this off a second time?
That's not correct. Ditching is very hard. Mess up your angle or sink rate or roll even slightly and you'll be in pieces. Same if the water doesn't cooperate.
One interesting thing is that it happened with an Airbus. The flight computers actually modified Sully's inputs on pitch by about 2 degrees, which ensured a softer splashdown than what Sully was commanding.
But that was a very subtle adjustment. Sully was an experienced pilot, with Glider training too.